There’s so much to love about Sarah Silverman’s appearance on last night’s Jimmy Kimmel Live, starting with the fact that they’re officially back together! And even though nothing really ever happens on these shows that’s an actual surprise (sorry to pull back that curtain), I want to believe that Sarah’s screams of protest were sincere when Jimmy showed a clip of her audition for Annie as a child. And then she asked him if he “made sweet love” to anyone while they were apart. And then he asked her the same thing. And then he proposed to T.I. All the beautiful fake awkwardness and awww after the jump (also: funny stuff.)

Part One: Jimmy shows Sarah’s video skeleton:

Part Two: The secret handshake:

Part Three: Jimmy proposes to T.I.:

Perfect.